
President Donald Trump took aim at Mexico last week, in the wake of the rout of his party in the midterm elections. The “INVASION of our Country is taking place again. Huge CARAVANS are forming and beginning their illegal march through Mexico,” he announced on Truth Social. He lobbed threats of tariffs at Mexico “if they don’t stop them.”
Trump’s renewed anti-immigrant fearmongering — a highlight of the campaign that won him a return to the White House — came as joint U.S. and Mexican military counter-cartel efforts are growing, new details about expanded covert CIA anti-drug operations in Mexico have come to light, and fears of worsening relations and even unilateral U.S. attacks south of the border are on the rise in Mexico.
The Trump administration has, over the last two years, expanded counter-drug efforts across the Americas through a plethora of initiatives from extrajudicial killings of suspected drug traffickers in the Caribbean and Pacific Ocean to ground operations by elite troops in Ecuador to enhanced efforts alongside Mexican forces.
“Right now, we have historic cooperation, military-to-military,” self-styled War Secretary Pete Hegseth said last year. This year, his department established the Joint Interagency Task Force-Counter Cartel to “identify, disrupt, and dismantle cartel operations posing a threat to the United States along the U.S.-Mexico border.” At the same time, the CIA reportedly used a cartel-compromised prosecutor to expand its operations in Mexico after President Claudia Sheinbaum blocked such efforts. (The covert operations only came to light when CIA operatives died during a mission.)
“U.S. military aid to Mexico in the ‘war on drugs’ echoes the same failures of the ‘war on terror.’”
The Trump administration’s latest initiatives are just the latest in a decadeslong string of U.S. security assistance efforts with Mexico that have failed spectacularly, according to a new report by the World Peace Foundation at Tufts University’s Fletcher School released in collaboration with the Costs of War project at Brown University. The analysis, shared exclusively with The Intercept, examines close to 15 years of U.S. and Mexican efforts to combat the drug trade. It offers a stark rebuke of past U.S. efforts, and suggests the Trump administration’s current paradigm for counter-drug policy in Mexico — and counter-cartel policy across the Americas more broadly — is destined to fail.
“U.S. military aid to Mexico in the ‘war on drugs’ echoes the same failures of the ‘war on terror,’” said Stephanie Savell, director of the Costs of War project. “U.S. security assistance in both cases has fueled forever wars marked by protracted militarization, spiraling violence, and widespread civilian harm. These conflicts negatively impact human rights, the economy, and civil institutions.”
Despite billions of dollars in U.S. aid over decades, the human, financial, and political costs of Mexico’s drug war have skyrocketed, according to the new report. The U.S. poured $3.3 billion into Mexico’s interdiction and counter-drug operations through the Mérida Initiative from 2008 to 2021. The researchers found that while Plan Mérida was originally slated to be a shared effort to strengthen government institutions, target crime networks, and reduce cross-border drug flows, both the U.S. and Mexico consistently failed to meet benchmarks, as political will ebbed and flowed and implantation of projects frequently faltered. As a result, in Mexico, drug violence spiked, homicide rates tripled, and government authority crumbled. North of the border, drug demand continued apace and overdose deaths surged, while little was done in the U.S. to stem the flow of firearms and cash that fuels the drug trade.
The authors of the report, Aileen Teague, an assistant professor of international affairs at Texas A&M, and Peyton McGuire, an adjunct professor of political science at Georgia Gwinnett College, detailed the immense human toll of violence in Mexico: more than 460,000 homicides since 2006.
“Despite expanded military deployments under Mérida and its successors, Mexico’s homicide rates reached historic highs between 2016 and 2019,” they wrote, adding: “Civilians have borne the overwhelming share of this violence: massacres, kidnappings, and targeted killings have become widespread.” More than 130,000 people have also been reported missing. Femicides, the term for gender-motivated killings, have also spiked during the drug war. Reported femicides increased from 427 in 2015 to 1,004 in 2021 — a 135 percent increase. Last year, in Sinaloa state alone, 105 women were killed. It was the highest toll in 14 years; 73 of the killings were investigated as femicides.
The massive death toll is directly attributable to the U.S. “Many of these homicides are inflicted by firearms trafficked from the United States, which remain a principal source of weapons used by Mexican criminal organizations,” according to Teague and McGuire. No less than Secretary of State Marco Rubio admitted the same. “Many of the weapons that are in the hands of these cartels are weapons that have been purchased from a source in the United States,” Rubio admitted in 2025. “These weapons have been trafficked.” An Intercept investigation also found that cartels have even been able to procure ammunition produced for the U.S. military.
Despite clear evidence of the carnage and its cause, most violence in Mexico goes unreported and unpunished. Research shows that in nearly 95 percent of cases, violent crimes go unsolved, exposing massive deficiencies in the Mexican government’s ability to deter, investigate, and prosecute organized crime. The carnage, much of it inflicted by cartels, is inextricably bound to declining state authority. Recent reporting by the Wall Street Journal highlighted the control of cartels across Mexico. An estimated one-third of the country’s territory is controlled by criminal groups — such as the Sinaloa Cartel and the Jalisco New Generation Cartel — according to U.S. government estimates. “This erosion in territorial governance is both a cause and consequence of violence,” write Teague and McGuire.
U.S. and Mexican efforts to target drug kingpins have fractured criminal groups and caused a proliferation of localized conflicts, overwhelming the abilities of local governments and law enforcement to contain them. “In turn, weakened institutions proved unable to contain or deter violence, creating a self-reinforcing cycle in which violence degrades state capacity, and diminished state capacity enables further violence,” according to the report.
As local police forces have faltered, military involvement in law enforcement has fueled rampant state violence. Widespread abuses by Mexican security forces, including torture, extrajudicial killings, and enforced disappearances, have been exhaustedly documented by NGOs like Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch.
Beyond its direct impacts on victims and survivors and the authority of the Mexican state, violence has also devastated Mexico’s economy. The economic burden of the bloodshed, in just 2021 alone, was almost $200 billion, roughly 15 percent of Mexico’s gross domestic product. That total has since increased to as much as $250 billion or nearly 18 percent of GDP.
In the wake of the failures of the Plan Mérida and similar militarized U.S.-Mexican counter-drug efforts, the Trump administration has pushed Mexico to destroy the cartels using tariffs, immigration enforcement, and threats of unilateral military operations — such as drone strikes — as leverage on Sheinbaum. Her government has made repeated concessions such as deepened intelligence sharing, expediting the transfer of high-profile imprisoned traffickers to U.S. custody, and using U.S. intelligence to kill Nemesio Oseguera Cervantes, known as “El Mencho,” leader of the Jalisco New Generation Cartel. This latter operation threw into broad relief the continued perils for Mexico in placating the U.S., as violence then erupted across 10 states, including arson attacks, assaults on security forces, and road blockades.
The violence and instability stoked by the Trump administration in Mexico has been mirrored across the Americas, amid the aggressive diplomatic and military engagement dubbed the Donroe Doctrine, a bastardization of the 1823 Monroe Doctrine. Earlier this year, a report by the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data project found that “U.S. pressure on organized crime is accelerating the spread of militarized security approaches in the region.” This volatility was set to “fuel an increase in violence throughout the rest of Trump’s term, potentially undermining any short-term improvements achieved through hardline approaches.”
The Donroe Doctrine has been used to justify strikes on civilian boats in the Caribbean Sea and Pacific Ocean; an attack on Venezuela and the abduction of its president; the CIA operations in Mexico; expanded partnerships with Colombia, Guatemala, Honduras, and Panama; joint counter-cartel operations in Ecuador dubbed “Operation Total Extermination”; and increased military and intelligence operations elsewhere in Latin America. It may be utilized to justify military operations in Mexico, too.
Even though Sheinbaum noted the so-called caravan of Central American immigrants was about 2,000 miles from the U.S. border and not moving northward, Trump continued lobbing threats this week. “They will not be allowed in,” Trump said on Monday. “They said that they were going to stop them, and if they don’t stop them, we’re going to put heavy tariffs on Mexico.”
This fearmongering follows the recent promotion of Trump’s xenophobic adviser Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff. The chief architect of the Donroe Doctrine, who oversaw the closure of the U.S. southern border and Trump’s mass deportation campaign, Miller has been an advocate of extreme hard-line anti-Mexican policies and has seemed to advocate for even greater militarization of U.S. policy in the Americas. “Cartels that operate in this hemisphere are the ISIS and al-Qaida of this hemisphere and must be treated just as ruthlessly,” Miller said earlier this year, adding that “hard power” and lethal force — not criminal justice — must be employed.
The new report by the World Peace Foundation demonstrates that decades of militarized security cooperation has repeatedly failed. The lessons of the Mérida Initiative, according to the report, indicate that any new policy must focus on the “structural drivers of the drug economy — demand, arms, finance, and institutional weakness — on both sides of the border.”
After decades of futility and bloodshed, Teague and McGuire say that U.S. security assistance to its partner to the south needs a complete reset. “Moving forward,” they wrote, “a more effective U.S.-Mexico (and by extension, U.S.-Latin America) security framework will require a fundamental recalibration away from enforcement-dominant, militarized approaches toward a genuinely binational strategy that addresses the full political economy of the drug trade.”
Neither the White House nor Hegseth’s office responded to repeated requests for comment.
Source: The Intercept · 2026-11-19